| Records | Captains | MVP | Batting Average Leader | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2002: | 10-22 | Victor Molina Evin Vasquez Patrick Gaffny |
Victor Molina | Victor Molina .404 |
| 2003: | 11-24 | Patrick Gaffny Anthony Arias |
Anthony Arias | Juan Ortiz .313 |
| 2004: | 27-20 | Patrick Gaffny Anthony Arias |
Patrick Gaffny | Torres .373 |
| 2005: | 21-18-1 | Jeremy Marion Ken Olisky Dave Iacono |
Ken Olisky | Ken Olisky .382 |
| 2006: | 34-16 | --- | Jeremy Marion | Jeremy Marion .387 |
| 2007: | 33-16 | Joey Eugenio | Tom Englehardt | Tom Englehardt .463 |
| 2008: | 34-23 | --- | Tom Englehardt | Tom Englehardt .493 |
| 2009: | 28-20-1 | Tom Englehardt | Tom Englehardt |
Tom Englehardt .467 |
| 2010: | 26-25 | --- | Edwin Pena |
Edwin Pena.407 |
| 2011 |
24-26 |
Kevin Michael Reynaldo Nunez |
Kevin Michael | Jose Rodriquez .381 |
| 2012 |
22-30 |
Gary Lunetta |
Eridani Dume | Eridani Dume .322 |
| 2013 |
35-18 |
--- |
Chris O'Hare | Victor Lebron .366 |
| 2014 |
37-17 |
--- | Davidson Peguero .418 | |
| 2015 |
30-15 |
--- | Devin Perry .397 | |
| 2016 |
19-29 |
--- | Sam Schroeder .307 | |
| 2017 |
26-25 |
--- | Angel Perez Vargas .386 | |
| 2018 |
31-19 |
--- | Mitchell Lundholm .327 | |
| 2019 |
42-16 |
--- | Mitchell Lundholm .456 | |
| 2020 |
14-4 |
--- | Mitchell Lundholm .466 | |
| 2021 |
31-22 |
--- | Mitchell Lundholm .330 | |
| 2022 |
29-30 |
--- |
Nicholas Lucchese .402 | |
| 2023 |
29-25 |
--- |
Ivanuel Hernandez | Ivanuel Hernandez .495 |
NAIA Baseball Top 25 Appearances
2006 (Ranked #25 in final poll) Sunrise Conference Championships
2005
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010 2011
NAIA Region X Championships
2005
2006
2007
2008 (NAIA disbanded the regions following the 2008 season)
NAIA East Coast Super Regional Appearances NAIA
Best of Three Series
2005: Lost 2-0 to Ohio Dominican University
2006: Lost 2-0 to Seton Hill (PA.) University
2007: Lost 2-0 to Walsh (OH.) University
2008: Lost 2-0 to Ohio Dominican University
Best of Three Series
2009: Lost 2-1 to Brescia (KY.) University
2010: Lost 2-1 to Ohio Dominican University 2011: Lost 2-0 to Edward Waters (FL.)
NAIA Opening Round Appearances
Double-Elimination Tournament Format
2021: 0-2, Lost to USC-Beaufort 7-4 & #18 Bryant (Tenn.) 13-5 | Lakeland, Fla. Bracket
2022: 0-2, Lost to Loyola (La.) 13-2 & #14 University of Science & Arts (Okla.) 13-2 | Shreveoport, La. Bracket
2023: 0-2, Lost to (RV) Point Park (Pa.) 20-3 & (RV) Cumberland (Tenn.) 17-9 | Upland, Ind. Bracket